3_sport
π Health and biotech π Society
Women's health comes to the forefront in medicine

Why are sportswomen excluded from scientific studies?

Juliana Antero, Epidemiological researcher at the Institut national du sport de l'expertise et de la performance
On March 12th, 2024 |
3 min reading time
Juliana Antero
Juliana Antero
Epidemiological researcher at the Institut national du sport de l'expertise et de la performance
Key takeaways
  • Women are under-represented and overlooked in sport research, making up just 35% of participants in sports science studies.
  • The menstrual and hormonal cycle can have an impact on results, so a better understanding of women’s physiology is needed.
  • Oestrogens are thought to have anabolic properties that are beneficial to muscle building and recovery.
  • Training needs to be adapted to each woman’s individual profile and cycle.
  • To achieve this, research programmes are being set up to help sportswomen improve their performance by taking into account the menstrual cycle.

Women are still under-rep­re­sent­ed in sports per­for­mance stud­ies. For­mer sports­woman Juliana Antero has long been affect­ed by the stress of irreg­u­lar men­stru­al cycles. In order to help spread aware­ness and com­bat this inequal­i­ty, she has launched the EMPOW’HER research pro­gramme to sup­port all sports­women1.

Why are women under-represented in scientific studies on sports performance? 

Women account for only 35% of par­tic­i­pants in sports sci­ence stud­ies. Most of the med­ical, nutri­tion­al and train­ing pro­to­cols that sports­women fol­low are devel­oped for male ath­letes. Some sci­en­tists jus­ti­fy this absence by the influ­ence that the men­stru­al cycle can have on women’s sci­en­tif­ic results and per­for­mance. But that’s pre­cise­ly why these stud­ies are nec­es­sary! If we want to opti­mise women’s sport­ing results, we need to know more about the impact of female phys­i­ol­o­gy on their performance.

What is the aim of your EMPOW’HER project?

The main aim of EMPOW’HER (Explor­ing Men­stru­al Peri­ods Of Women ath­letes to Esca­late Rank­ing) is to max­imise the per­for­mance of female ath­letes by opti­mis­ing their train­ing respons­es through adapt­ed train­ing loads, in syn­er­gy with their phys­i­ol­o­gy and men­stru­al cycle. Since 2020, we have mon­i­tored around a hun­dred top-lev­el sports­women who took part in the Tokyo Sum­mer Olympics, the Bei­jing Win­ter Olympics and/or are prepar­ing to take part in the Paris Olympics. Almost a dozen dis­ci­plines are cov­ered: row­ing, cycling, swim­ming, ski­ing, wrestling, gym­nas­tics, and triathlon. 

Every day for a peri­od of six months, these women record their data on an appli­ca­tion: the qual­i­ty of their sleep, mus­cu­lar pains if they feel any, pains linked to their men­stru­a­tion, their state of stress, etc. In this way, we can observe the influ­ence of hor­mon­al fluc­tu­a­tions on the well-being and train­ing of these sports­women. In this way, we can observe the influ­ence of hor­mon­al fluc­tu­a­tions on the well-being and train­ing of these sports­women. The ini­tial results show that even mild symp­toms reduce the qual­i­ty of their train­ing, and that they are more or less fit at dif­fer­ent times of the cycle. In par­tic­u­lar, there are sig­nif­i­cant inter-indi­vid­ual differences

A US decree to adapt sports train­ing to the men­stru­al cycle

In 2019, the Amer­i­can women’s foot­ball team won the World Cup for the fourth time. How can we explain the dom­i­nance of the Unit­ed States in a sport tra­di­tion­al­ly dom­i­nat­ed by Euro­pean nations in the men’s game? In 1972, a decree was passed ban­ning all dis­crim­i­na­tion based on gen­der in schools and uni­ver­si­ties in the Unit­ed States. This was the cat­a­lyst that gave women access to bet­ter oppor­tu­ni­ties in sport. The team is now advised by Amer­i­can researcher Georgie Bru­in­vels, who holds a doc­tor­ate on the impact of iron defi­cien­cy and men­stru­al cycles on sport­ing per­for­mance. The researcher has adapt­ed the team’s train­ing accord­ing­ly. An approach that has clear­ly proved effec­tive with female footballers.

Is it possible to choose the date of competitions according to your menstrual cycle?

No, but you can adapt your train­ing sched­ule to the dif­fer­ent phas­es of your cycle and antic­i­pate cer­tain con­straints. For exam­ple, increas­ing the over­all vol­ume of exer­cise over the month by reduc­ing the inten­si­ty on cer­tain days. If you take these issues into account before­hand, you can even take advan­tage of cer­tain hor­mones. For exam­ple, the quan­ti­ty of oestro­gen is high­er dur­ing ovu­la­tion. Often per­ceived as an obsta­cle to per­for­mance, this hor­mone has inter­est­ing ana­bol­ic prop­er­ties for mus­cle build­ing and recov­ery. Our hypoth­e­sis is that it may be pos­si­ble to take advan­tage of hor­mon­al fluctuations.

How do sportswomen approach the subject of menstruation and possible pain?

It’s still a bit of a taboo sub­ject. The major­i­ty of coach­es are male. Sports­women feel allowed to talk about their injuries and mus­cle pain, but not always about their hor­mon­al cycle.

When it comes to peri­od pains, there is usu­al­ly an expla­na­tion. To begin with, it’s impor­tant to seek a doctor’s advice to find the cause. Is it linked to a cycle dis­or­der such as endometrio­sis? Could med­ica­tion be effec­tive in reliev­ing the pain? Final­ly, are there any non-med­i­c­i­nal meth­ods – although not sci­en­tif­i­cal­ly proven – that can relieve men­stru­al pain? Sports­women need to be per­suad­ed to con­sult a doc­tor, a gynae­col­o­gist or an endocri­nol­o­gist if they are to over­come these pains and be able to train normally.

How were you able to objectively assess performance in your study?

For non-timed sports such as row­ing and fenc­ing, it was dif­fi­cult to mea­sure an objec­tive per­for­mance, so we had to rely on the ath­letes’ own com­ments. But with cycling or foot­ball, we have pow­er or move­ment sen­sors and we can cal­cu­late the effort pro­duced by the ath­lete. So, we’ve been able to link this data with women’s hor­mon­al profiles.

We are now try­ing to mea­sure the effect of train­ing adapt­ed to women’s indi­vid­ual pro­files and cycles. That’s the aim of our next research projects. There’s still a lot to be done, for exam­ple, sup­port­ing sports­women on issues relat­ed to the pelvic floor to pre­vent uri­nary incon­ti­nence dur­ing exercise.

Marina Julienne
1https://​www​.insta​gram​.com/​f​e​m​p​o​w​e​r​_​s​p​o​r​t​ives/

Our world explained with science. Every week, in your inbox.

Get the newsletter